>

"He who treads the path in search of knowledge, Allah will make easy for him a path to Paradise."

Al-Kulayni and Tahreef

Muhammad bin Ya`qub al-Kulayni is disputably the top Twelver Shia Hadith scholar to ever walk the earth. They trust him and honor him to no end, even going as far as bestowing upon him the title of “Thiqat-ul-Islam”. Al-Kulayni is the author of their main book of Hadith “al-Kafi” which is a large 8 volume collection of traditions and beliefs relied upon by the Twelvers throughout their history. However, is he a Muslim who believes in the authenticity of our holy book or is he on the other side of the fence? Twelvers will jump right up and shout: “It is the evil Wahhabi scholars who accuse Kulayni of Tahrif!!” Is this the truth though? We find out below, A- The biggest of Shia scholars testify that al-Kulayni clearly believes in Tahrif. Shia leader al-Fayd al-Kashani writes in the sixth introduction of his book “Tafsir al-Safi”: [As for the belief of our teachers may Allah have mercy on them, then what is apparent from Thiqat-ul-Islam al-Kulayni is that he believed in the corruption of the Qur’an and that it suffered from deletions. This is because he narrated texts in this regard inside his book al-Kafi and never criticized them in any way, although he mentioned in the introduction of his book that he trusts whatever he...

Response to: Ask Those Who Know

Response to: Ask Those Who Know by Sh. Uthmān Al-Khamīs Translated by Hānī Salḥab Al-Ṭarābulsī *Note: The original page referencing provided by Sh. Uthmān Al-Khamīs was kept. Though, we have added the titles of the chapters in English from Tijani’s Ask Those Who Know for those that want to review the original text. **Those that are experiencing difficulties reading the text on mobile due to dropped symbols, please access the Full Version of the website at the very bottom of this article. Back to Exposing Tijani page   1- Tijani said on pg.7 [Ask Those Who Know / Introduction]: Through this, the nation would unite under a fundamental rule, a rule that forms the center pivot of everything founded by the Messenger when he said: “I am leaving among you two weighty things. If you hold onto them you shall never go astray. They are Allah’s book and the progeny from my household.” Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim.   I say: This is a lie since this version of the report is not found in Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim. Here is what Muslim wrote: From Zayd bin Arqam: One day, the Prophet (peace be upon him) stood to deliver a sermon in a pond known as Khum, located between Makkah and Madinah. He praised...

Response to: Then I Was Guided

Response to: Then I Was Guided by Sh. Uthman Al-Khamīs Translated by Hani Salhab Al-Tarabulsi *Note: The original page referencing provided by Sh. Uthman Al-Khamees was kept. Though, we have added the titles of the chapters in English from Tijani’s Then I Was Guided for those that want to review the original text. Points 32 and 61 do not seem to have been included in the English translation of Then I Was Guided. **Those that are experiencing difficulties reading the text on mobile due to dropped symbols, please access the Full Version of the website at the very bottom of this article. Back to Exposing Tijani page 1- Tijani writes on pg.24 [Then I was Guided / In Egypt]: Some of al-Azhar’s Shaykhs used to come to these meetings and liked what I recited from the Qur’ānic verses and the sayings of the great Prophet Muḥammad (peace be upon him). Besides that, they were impressed by my strong arguments and asked me from which university I had graduated from. I used to answer them proudly that I graduated from al-Zaytūnah University.   And on the same page, he said: Some of them even told me that my place was there, i.e. at al-Azhar… I sat on the VIP rostrum...

The mass-transmitted secret! (12th Imam’s Mutawatir birth)

For those of you unable to grasp the sarcasm in the title, it is the fact that Shia keep claiming that the birth of their 12th Imam is common knowledge and popular to the point where it is Mutawatir. At the same time they want you to believe that the 12th Imam’s birth is a secret that was concealed from everyone and the Imam al-`Askari made sure that nobody would find out that he had a son. Yes, a brazen contradiction and we will elaborate below. When debating the Shia concerning their 12th Imam, they will tell you that his birth and existence are agreed upon between all Muslims. They will make it seem as if you are sinful for even doubting such a clear matter, as if you are doubting the existence of the Prophet (saw) himself. How can one deny a matter that is Mutawatir? The nation mass transmitted the story of the 12th Imam, the son of al-Hasan al-`Askari!! However, when you stop and think, you notice that historians never mentioned anything regarding the man, as if he never really existed. Although a few geneologists may list him as a son for al-`Askari yet these guys only do so based on the stories of the Shia...

Join TwelverShia.net Telegram group & Discussion forum

TwelverShia.net Telegram TwelverShia.net Forum

Our Mission:


The TwelverShia.net team's goal is to provide the authentic alternative to the popular Islamic history that is propagated online through various Shia websites and media hubs.

TwelverShia.net Forum

Recent Articles

Search:

Al-Kulayni and Tahreef