>

"He who treads the path in search of knowledge, Allah will make easy for him a path to Paradise."

Response to: Holy Prophet asws Desire to Bury Ayesha

The following is a response to SlaveOfAhlubait’s “Holy prophet asws desire to bury ayesha (authentic narration)”. The article can be found on his blog and on the Wilayat website. The article contains a narration that SlaveOfAhlubait implies is evidence that the Prophet – peace be upon him – hated A’isha. The narration goes as follows: “ayesha says that the day the disease which caused death of holy prophet started, he came to my house and said: oh my headache, i also said oh my head; upon this holy prophet asws said: i wish what has to happen should happen in my life, and i prepare you well and bury you; i said: your intentions are something else, you will marry the same day and and spend night with lady; holy prophet asws said: oh my head! call your father and your brother so that i write letter for abu bakar because i fear that the one who would say will say, and the one who would desire would desire that i am more rightful to caliphate; and allah and all muslim will not accept anyone other than abu bakar [musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 306]” The narration is an obvious explicit merit for A’isha, because the Prophet – peace be upon...

Response to: Ayesha and her Narrations: an Analysis

The following is a response to SlaveOfAhlubait’s “ayesha and her narrations: an analysis”. The article can be found on his blog and on the Wilayat website. This article, by SlaveOfAhlubait, collects “contradictions” in the narrations of A’isha, in order to suggest that she was a lousy hadith narrator, and thus, we should reject her hadiths altogether. SlaveOfAhlubait provides three examples of these so-called “contradictions”: -INCIDENT OF JEW LADY AND PUNISHMENT IN GRAVE -PRAYER OF CHASHT (dhuhaa) – SHOULD LIZARDS BE KILLED OR NOT? We shall respond to each of these allegations with the necessary evidences. 1- INCIDENT OF JEW LADY AND PUNISHMENT IN GRAVE SlaveOfAhlubait spends a good deal of time providing narrations in which the Prophet – peace be upon him – is asked about the punishment of the grave. His answer differs in the hadiths, even though the primary narrator of the hadith is A’isha, who has narrated the hadith to several student: Jasra, Sa’eed, Urwa, Thakwan, and Masrooq. We would like to add that Amra is also one of the narrators of this hadith, but SlaveOfAhlubait forgot to include her narration. Some of the narrations suggest that the Prophet – peace be upon him – was not aware of the punishment of the grave when he...

Response to: Ayesha and her Ability to Understand Quran

The following is a response to SlaveOfAhlubait’s “Ayesha and her ability to understand quran”. The article can be found on his blog and on the Wilayat website. The narration is as follows: “ayesha says that once she asked holy prophet asws about the verse {[Shakir] And those who give what they give (in alms) while their hearts are full of fear that to their Lord they must return (mominoon/60),} ; she said o prophet asws! does this verse speak of one who steals, does zina and drinks wine? upon this holy prophet said: no, it speaks of one who offers prayers, fasts, and gives charity and he is having fear of allah” {molvi zafar iqbal says narration is sahih as per Albany} [musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 345] SlaveOfAhlubait uses this narration to suggest that A’isha is ignorant when it comes to understanding the meanings of the Qur’an. This is a silly accusation since the Arabic text of the Qur’an is vague regarding the meaning of the verse. Allah the Almighty states: الَّذِينَ يُؤْتُونَ مَا آتَوْا وَقُلُوبُهُمْ وَجِلَةٌ The terms “Yu’toon ma Aatoo” can hold various meanings. It can mean “those that commit what they have committed” or “those that give what they give” or “those that enter forth where they have...

Response to ayesha mocking others: sahih sanad

The following is a response to SlaveOfAhlubait’s “ayesha mocking others: sahih sanad”. The article can be found on his blog and the Wilayat website.   The article contains the following narration: “ayesha says that once i started mockery of a man or a woman in the presence of holy propet asws, so he said that if i get something even more in return, i will not mock anyone nor i like mockery; i said that safia is this much, and then i pointed of her being dwarf/short heighted; upon this prophet asws said that you have said something which if mixed with water of sea, it will change colour of that” {molvi zafar iqbal mentions there that narration is sahih as per Albany and hasan sahih as per timidhi} [musnad ahmad, urdu, vol 11, page 419-420]   There is little doubt of the authenticity of this report, though we find it to be an indication of the honesty of A’isha. It is not a common act for one to speak of their own faults, and in this narration, A’isha confesses that the Prophet – peace be upon him – reprimanded her for backbiting. We do not find any other narrations in which A’isha backbites others, so one cannot say...

Join TwelverShia.net Telegram group & Discussion forum

TwelverShia.net Telegram TwelverShia.net Forum

Our Mission:


The TwelverShia.net team's goal is to provide the authentic alternative to the popular Islamic history that is propagated online through various Shia websites and media hubs.

TwelverShia.net Forum

Recent Articles

Search:

Response to: Holy Prophet asws Desire to Bury Ayesha